Lessons from Paraguay for the Region

Customers of Paraguay’s largest digital bank, Ueno Bank, discovered on November 3 that the app, cards and ATMs of the bank had stopped functioning. This had come in the wake of the Central Bank of Paraguay (BCP) starting a resolution process the previous day following the fall of the capital of the bank below half of the legal minimum. Just two days later, President Santiago Peña, who himself had been a shareholder in the group owning the bank until last year, resigned while the Congress was debating whether to begin impeachment proceedings against him. Anyone familiar with the scene around Yes Bank branches in India in March 2020 will feel right at home.

A cursory view of the situation would suggest that the ‘Paraguay model’ was finally over. For the past two years, it has been the success story of all reports on the region. The reading is misleading. Paraguay’s past two years contain for its neighbors lessons of what to emulate and what to avoid, and India’s own experience on fiscal rules and bank failures provides the reasons.

Let us start with the positives. The Fiscal Responsibility Law introduced in 2013 keeps the central government deficit within 1.5 percent of GDP. The BCP has inflation targeting at 3.5 percent with two points band above and below. The design is close to that of India’s Monetary Policy Committee of 4 ± 2 percent target from 2016. In January, the inflation rate was 2.7 percent, lower than the target, while the public debt was about 36 percent of GDP in April. Paraguay got its first investment-grade rating from Moody’s in July 2024 and S&P in December 2025. In South America, Chile, Peru and Uruguay alone enjoyed that status with S&P while Brazil and Colombia are both rated BB. It also issued bonds abroad using its national currency, the guaraní, something that Latin American governments could not do in decades.

All these achievements did not come from its wealth. Paraguay is an economy of soya cultivation and hydropower generation of about six million people. But the successive governments let the central bank alone and kept the deficit ceiling in law, even in the years they breached it.

They breached or suspended the deficit ceiling in almost all years since 2019. 2026 budget signed on December 31 aimed at returning to the rule. However, on the very day, the government recognized its outstanding bills worth US$1.27 billion to drug suppliers and road contractors. By August, it became clear that this year’s deficit will be 3.2 percent while next year’s will be 3.9 percent and the deficit ceiling pushed to 2028.

In India, there has been a similar experience. The FRBM Act introduced in 2003 had the deficit target that was deferred so many times that N.K. Singh committee suggested a debt anchor in 2017 and the loans made to Food Corporation of India hid the actual budget deficit. The outstanding bills of suppliers in Asunción do the same thing; the target is met on paper since payments are delayed. Now, the IMF’s review in June has asked Paraguay to introduce the debt anchor and make the expenditure recognition happen on the basis of delivery and not payments.

The bank failure is more serious. The banks’ position, on paper, had been healthy with the capital at 17.1 percent of risk-weighted assets and problem loans at 2.5 percent in September. Though BCP claimed to have warned Ueno in June about over-lending to companies linked to the owners of the bank, it had intervened only five months later. During the first half of this year, the loans made by Ueno increased by about 30 percent while deposits increased only by 10 percent. Also, at the beginning of his tenure, Peña himself had appointed the then head of Ueno, Carlos Carvallo, as the head of BCP supervising the bank.

This is a lesson that India learnt at a cost. Yes Bank had been reporting healthy capital ratios while its loans were filled with stressed corporate groups. Similarly, PMC Bank had hidden its exposure to real estate firm HDIL behind thousands of dummy accounts. In both the cases, the RBI had the powers necessary and used those quite late. The supervisor who gets the position from the bank he is supposed to supervise will act even later.

However, the resolution itself is a piece of art that should be replicated. The Paraguay Deposit Guarantee Law introduced in 2003 guarantees up to 75 monthly minimum wage per depositor which works out to be about US$28,000. It has provided guidelines for the wind-up of a failed bank. Within a week, the guarantee fund managed to provide at least provisional payments to 93 percent of 1.87 million insured depositors, about US$340 million in five days. But the depositors of PMC had to wait much longer; and it took the increase of the DICGC cover to ₹5 lakh in 2020 and the amendment to the DICGC Act in 2021 to bring a 90-day payment time.

Thus, the advice to finance ministers from Bogotá to Buenos Aires is quite specific. Start with the Paraguayan model; a deficit ceiling law, an inflation targeting central bank left alone and a deposit guarantee fund paying in days. Then fix what Paraguay did not; give the fiscal rule a debt anchor and accrual accounting system so that arrears cannot hide and have a cooling off period and a strict conflict of interest bar for those moving between ownership of a bank, bank supervision and governance. In September, Fitch had said that a broader revenue base and better governance and institutions were the things that separated Paraguay from its third investment grade rating. After Ueno, the condition is the whole story.

India took about two decades and two bank failures to learn both lessons. Latin America can learn them from Paraguay’s past two years at a much lower cost.

  • Shankit Kumar Gupta

    Shankit Kumar Gupta is currently a Doctoral candidate in Latin American Studies at the Centre for the Study of the Americas, School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi. His work focuses on analysing International Relations along the themes of Political Economy, Energy and Environmental issues, particularly in Latin America and Colombia.

  • Moitrayee Devi Baruah

    Moitrayee Devi Baruah is a doctoral candidate in Latin American Studies at the Centre for the Study of the Americas, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.

You may also like